I don't know.
Coca Cola was a fierce bitch, with awesome body strength, who TRIED to finish ... but she never had the ability to "finish with one hold" like
Silverback, nor did she have anywhere near his intelligence or athleticism. She was just awesomely strong, had bad
intentions, and was game as a bitch could be.
Of the Coca Cola dogs I had, only
Stormbringer could kill a dog with one throat hold, and while his awesome body strength came from Coki, his his intelligence and pit savvy came from Poncho. None of Stormy's littermates could do this (although his brother, the blond
Crews' Sandy, threw dogs that would finish). Coki's daughter, the blonde
Red Sonja was pretty much just like Coki. Coki's daughter
Bandana was super-fast and was always looking for the guts or stomach ... and she was a red/rednose ... but, strong and relentless as she was, she was not as awesome a finisher as either Stormbringer or Silverback. Her best son,
Ch Vengence, sired by Silverback's sire,
Ouch!, was a chocolate ... and he was a tactical ace, with a heavy mouth, but I never heard of him being a total finisher, though he did break the windpipe of the last dog he faced. (Likewise, Vengence's blonde brother
Techno threw the devastating
Ch Tulipa (4xW, 4xBIS), but she was a buckskin. So the chocolate/seal color is not as dominant in Coki dogs (for me anyway) as it was in Silverback. The trait of finishing in Silverback dogs has been 100% seal so far.
Therefore, to answer your question, my # 1 priority would be THE TRAITS not the color. Your
Ch Blaze was a chocolate, and he is obviously the standard you're after, as he too was a vastly better dog than Coca Cola herself. Color-wise, black is closer to chocolate (especially if the "black" is really a dark seal), so I would lean that way ...
unless the rednose was the better dog. For me, with Coki dogs, Stormbringer was by far the best ... and he was a red/rednose and a light-years better all-around animal than his mother Coki. In short, I am not sure I would make Coki the standard, as she was able to produce better dogs than herself. I would make the ace the standard ... though it is hard for an ace to be able to produce better than himself.
So I would go with TRAITS first, and then (if all else was equal) go with the color that best falls in line with the BEST dog close up that you're trying to breed to.
Jack